Overview
If you’ve read my blog for any length of time, you are aware that Dakota is our hyperactive Lab and we’ve been working with her since Day 1, particularly with walks. We believe that walking dogs is a critical exercise – not for the physical exercise that it provides, but for the discipline and mental exercise that dogs receive from walking on leash.
Unfortunately, Dakota would rather choke herself than walk at our side. We use both chain and nylon leashes when walking the dogs, and in order to keep Dakota at our side during the walk, we’ve shortened the leash by wrapping it around our hands. It’s not long until the leash has cut off the circulation, then frustration sets in, and the walk is not productive or enjoyable for any of us.
We purchased choke collars for the dogs, but then after doing some research, I don’t believe that they should be used in training dogs – only as reinforcement after the dog has learned to behave on leash. Especially Labs and Golden Retrievers – but any breed – are prone to suffering laryngeal paresis or paralysis that can be caused by trauma from collars; this can put the dog at risk especially during water retrieves, and is a primary concern with Dakota. In discussing choke collars, Dog Training Collars states:
Fit is very important with these collars. To size correctly, measure your dog’s neck with a string and ensure your choke collar is no more than 2-3 inches larger. Not only does too large a collar run the risk of slipping but the extra length of chain can result in far too strong a correction which may result in injury.
In addition, a choke collar must be put on correctly. Failure to place the collar correctly (by flipping the live and dead rings or allowing the rings to slip below the neck) can result in the collar not releasing pressure when positive results have been achieved. Training an animal requires both a negative (or undesirable) result followed by a positive reinforcing result. If the collar does not release pressure, no positive reinforcing signal is given for improved behavior.
As mentioned, incorrect use by the owner is another downside to choke collars. Owners may snap the lead too hard, not release quickly enough to provide positive reinforcement for good behavior or maintain pressure on the collar in a constant choke during the walk. Whatever positive benefits this type of dog training collar may impart are completely voided when used improperly.
And the Dog Owner’s Home Veterinary HandBook (James M. Giffin, MD and Liisa D. Carlson, DVM, Howell Book House, 3rd ed., 2000), choke chains can cause laryngeal trauma: Choke Chain injury can fracture the huoid bone and/or cause compression damage to the nerves of the pharynx and larynx… Dogs with laryngeal injuries often breathe normally at rest but show respiratory distress during exertion.
Criteria and Review
In an attempt to find a method of walking the dogs (ie. Dakota), we purchased Cesar Millan’s “Illusion Collar”. The following criteria were used in reviewing the Illusion Collar, based on manufacturer’s information.
1- The Illusion Collar Leash Set is designed to allow the owner to walk and train the dog using a slip collar correction, without having to stop and realign the collar to the proper position.
In the linked video clip, Dakota is wearing a slip collar during the first 50 seconds of the video, and an Illusion Collar during the remainder of the video. As the video clip shows, the Illusion Collar maintained its proper position on Dakota’s neck and although she continues to pull, there is little tension on the leash. Unless standard collars and choke chains are too tight, they will work their way down the dog’s neck to their shoulders.
2- It provides the ability to give a firm, yet quick and gentle, correction that eases up when the pressure is released. A normal slip collar falls to the base of the neck near the shoulders, which does not provide as much control.
The collar’s ability to provide a firm, quick and gentle correction is based on the handler. As with any product, it can be misused and abused. With proper use, the collar does provide firm, quick and gentle corrections – from personal experience, this is probably due more to the fact that the collar does provide more control and handler doesn’t become frustrated with the dog. The collar does ease up when pressure is released and as the videos show, maintains its proper position while the choke chain slips to the base of the neck.
3- A harness fits over the dog’s chest, shoulders, and ribs. The Illusion collar fits the entire length of the neck to provide proper positioning for the corrective slip collar.
We purchased harnesses for the dogs some time ago as an alternative to collars, however the harnesses did appear to empower the dogs, and especially with Dakota, it encouraged her to pull. Sophie and Squirt who normally walk well with us, began pulling while on walks wearing harnesses. Since the Illusion Collar distributes pressure along the entire length of the neck, there are fewer pressure points than with collars, which reduce the chance of throat damage that could end their retrieving careers.
4- The strongest muscles in a dog’s neck are at the base and shoulder girdle. If you look at an Alaskan sled dog pulling a load, you will see that the harness fits around the base of the neck at the shoulder. All the pulling strength of the dog is concentrated in that area, which is why a slip collar in this position is ineffective for correcting a behavior.
As previously stated, standard harnesses seem to empower the dogs, and with Dakota being the obsessive, driven dog that she is, it seemed to encourage her to pull even more. Standard collars and choke chains did choke Dakota but did not deter her.
5- The leash attaches to the larger “O” ring on the slip collar. The collar will not work if the leash is attached to the smaller ring. The flat strap collars provide a comfortable framework to keep the slip collar in the proper position for instant correction.
The collar was not tested using the smaller ring, only the larger ring as instructed. The collar appeared to distribute the pressure and provide support along the entire length of the neck, via the flat strap.
6- The correction is performed by a quick pull on the leash which is attached to the larger “O” ring on the slip collar. Then the pressure is released, and the slip collar returns to the slack, loose position.
The collar was tested only on Dakota. While wearing the collar, a fewer number of corrections were needed and although she continued to pull, there was very little pressure on my hand from the leash. Prior to using the Illusion collar, pressure from the leash bit into our hands and cut off circulation.
7- As is standard dog training protocol, The Illusion collar is designed to be used when walking the dog on the left of the owner. If you walk your dog on the right side, the collar will not perform as well and may not release as quickly after a correction.
Since Dakota refuses to walk on the right and only on the left, the collar was not tested to fail if used on the right.
8- The slip collar does not open and must be able to slide over the dog’s head. You should measure at the base of the neck near the collar bone. This figure is roughly the same as the circumference of the dog’s head.
The slip collar slides over our Labs’ heads comfortably.
9- The collar will not fit most dogs weighing less than 18 lbs. If the base of your dog’s neck measures less than 13 inches, you should not use the collar. The materials, such as the width of the straps and the size of the “O” rings, are specifically designed for larger dogs.
The collar is used only on our Labs, which are larger dogs.
10- Dogs with a neck measurement of less than 13 inches; dogs with any breathing problems, such as “pushed-in faces” that restrict breathing; dogs with trachea or throat problems, such as Pomeranians; dogs with elongated, overly slender necks, such as Greyhounds.
Again, the collar is used only on our Labs, which are larger dogs with thick necks.
11- To maintain the Illusion Collar and Leash Set at peak performance, hand wash by swishing in a basin of cold water with a small amount of laundry detergent. We recommend using unscented detergent to ensure that your pet has no reaction to chemical fragrances. Then pat dry with a towel, re-shape, and hang to dry. Do not dry in dryer or use fabric softener! The use of fabric softener will likely result in loss of rigidity and poor performance, and repeated use of fabric softener will break down fibers prematurely.
Washing the collar as directed allows it to maintain its rigidity. As the linked video clip shows, I have found the Illusion collar to be very beneficial in Dakota’s training, which includes water retrieving (video is choppy when I move too fast for it to record). At times, the collar is wet for long periods of time and has not lost any of its rigidity.
Disclaimer and Safety Information
The Illusion collar is designed as a training aid for walking your dog. For the dog’s safety, no slip collar of any kind should be left on an unsupervised dog. The Illusion Collar & Leash Set is a training device intended to aid the owner in mastering the walk. Cesar Millan, Inc. does not condone using the collar on a full-time basis.
Never leave the dog unattended while the Illusion collar is in use. As is true with slip collars, buckle collars, and bandanas, there is a risk of choking if the collar is left on an unsupervised dog.
As is standard dog training practice, the Illusion Collar and Leash Set is designed to be used while walking the dog on the left. We apologize to those of you who may have difficulty using your left hand.
We do not recommend attaching other items to the Illusion collar. Nothing but the leash should be attached to the “O “ring(s) or the “A” collar. If you must add a dog tag due to city ordinance, the best place to attach it is the “D” piece.
If your dog’s neck measures less than 13 inches around the base of the neck, you should not use the collar. The Illusion collar is not intended for puppies under one year of age. Consult your local professional or veterinarian for further advice. The materials, such as the width of the straps and the size of the “O” rings, are specifically designed for larger dogs. Please note that the two rectangular keepers are to keep excess strap from flapping. Cesar Millan, Inc. is not liable for any modifications made to the collar.
We thank you for your understanding and cooperation and wish you the best of luck training your dog. Stay calm and assertive!
Summary
We found that the Illusion collar is very beneficial in controlling Dakota, who I’ve said on a number of occasions, is an obsessive and hyperactive Lab. In using a standard collar or choke chain, Dakota constantly pulls to the point that circulation is cut off in our hands. The Illusion collar does not prevent her from pulling, but it does greatly lessen the extent to which she can pull – I can literally walk her with one finger through the leash eyelet.
The Illusion collar provides her support along her entire neck, eliminating the single pressure point caused by standard collars and choke chains and reducing the potential of damaging her throat. In addition, the Illusion collar has been beneficial in training Dakota; in several of my recent videos, it is evident that I use the Illusion collar in her training.
I highly recommend the Illusion collar for the effectiveness that it provides in walking dogs as well as its adaptability for training purposes.
Response from Cesar Millan, Inc.
Thank you for allowing us to look this over! It’s great.
We’d love it if you could explain in the YouTube video description that you are comparing a regular slip collar to the Illusion collar in the video. Just so people know that the first collar is not the Illusion collar. Also, it’d be great if you add a link to your review in the video description, just to provide a little context.
Again, thank you for sending this our way, and we thank you for your support!